THIS RESTAURANT IS CLOSED Dexter’s Awards

Features
- Parking lot
- Dress code: Casual dressy
- Entertainment: Music nightly
- Full bar
- Great Wine List
- Kid-friendly
- Outdoor dining
- Reservations suggested
- Romantic setting

THIS RESTAURANT IS CLOSED Dexter’s Restaurant Review:
Part wine bar, part restaurant, the scene at Dexter’s Lake Mary is hip and fun, with colorful local art, sleek marble and wood tables and a chic glass wine case lending an urban vibe. A younger crowd gathers late night for the specialty cocktails and wide variety of wines, but the scene is considerably less rowdy earlier in the evening. The menu changes seasonally, and at lunch you’ll find eclectic choices like a tzatziki lamb burger and a Carolina barbecue shrimp wrap. For dinner, pistachio-crusted grouper and apple wood bacon-wrapped filet are standout entrées. Pair your meal with a glass or bottle of wine from the extensive, ever-changing collection. Dexter’s is known for its Sunday brunch; start your week on the right note with shrimp and grits and a peach mimosa, as good as it sounds.
![]()
|
- PHOTOS
- MORE MENUS
- Main Menu
- Fall Dinner Café Menu
- Brunch Menu
- Summer Dinner Cafe Menu
- Main Menu
- Fall Dinner Café Menu
- Brunch Menu
- Summer Dinner Cafe Menu
Cajun Lime Calamari
Served crisp, red pepper salsa, cool citrus remoulade. Available in: half / full
Dexter's Traditional Wings
Seven crisp, tangy wings made with our homemade hot Buffalo sauce
Dex-Mex Chicken Egg-Rolls
Blackened chicken, fire-roasted corn salsa, black beans, sweet onions, peppers and pepper jack cheese all rolled in a crispy Won-ton. Served with an avocado ranch dipping sauce
Southern Dill Chicken Nugs
Crisp, buttermilk battered white meat chicken breast served with a Carolina Gold Lava Mustard dipping sauce
Ahi Tuna Poke Bowl
Soy sesame ginger, marinated, Ahi tuna tossed with fresh avocado, green onions, and sesame seeds over Wakame seaweed salad served with crispy Wonton chips
Grilled Veggie Spring Garden Bowl
Shaved kale, grilled red onions, sautéed crimini mushrooms, cherry tomatoes, grilled zucchini, yellow squash planks, and pesto soaked feta cheese, tossed with an olive oil mustard vinaigrette
Chipotle Lime Chicken Salad
Crisp romaine, black bean-mango salsa, chimichurri tomato, guacamole, sour cream, cheese tortilla crisp, and chili lime vinaigrette
The Smith Salmon Salad
Arugula, mandarin oranges, sun-dried cranberries, pecans, red onions, tomatoes, Gorgonzola cheese, and olive oil-mustard vinaigrette
Caesar Salad
Dexter's own award winning homemade dressing. Available in: sm / reg. Add Chicken - Shrimp - Salmon - Mahi
Garden Green Salad
With a dressing of your choice. Available in: sm / reg. Add Chicken - Shrimp - Salmon - Mahi
Blackened Chicken & Shrimp Salad
Mixed greens, roasted corn and herbed tomatoes, grilled red onions, dill cucumber slaw, asiago tortilla, and chunky blue cheese dressing
Blackened Salmon Tacos
Three soft shell tortillas, avocado, black bean-corn salsa, cilantro cream cheese aioli
Fish N Chips
Local IPA beer battered cod filet, steak cut fries, served with a Key West tartar sauce
Eggplant Napoleon
Crispy fried, layered with spinach, ricotta, provolone and Parmesan cheeses, marinara sauce
Spicy Shrimp Provencal
Pan seared shrimp seasoned with curry, fresh garlic and sweet chili, tossed with Capellini Pasta, tomato chunks and green onions. (Mild, Medium or Hot) Substitute gluten free pasta
Parmesan Shells
Parmesan pasta shells tossed in a pan with scallions, peas, black pepper, garlic, grated Parmesan cheese and finished with a little heavy cream. Add chicken or shrimp. Substitute gluten free pasta
Grilled Mahi with Agave Pineapple Salsa
Fresh grilled Mahi served on Chef's Mix Micro Greens topped with agave pineapple salsa and finished with a garlic cilantro drizzle
Blackened Seafood Burrito
Lightly blackened seafood, black beans, mixed jack cheeses, homemade enchilada sauce, served with sour cream, guacamole, and Pico de Gallo salsa over a bed of yellow rice. Substitute chipotle chicken
Kutza's Dockside Catch
Blackened Mahi, Key West tartar, lettuce, tomato, and onion ring on a butter toasted Brioche bun, served with Kickin' Old Bay Chips
Uptown French Dip
House roasted beef, thyme au jus, toasted French baguette, aged white cheddar, Cremini mushrooms, garlic aioli, and Parmesan truffle fries
Dexter's Famous Grilled Colby Cheeseburger
8 oz. Fresh ground burger topped with melted Colby cheese, served with lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles on a toasted classic burger bun with Idaho fries. Add bacon | Add Cremini mushrooms
Dexter's Special
Featuring honey mesquite smoked turkey, smoked Gouda, house made lava mustard, mayonnaise, green leaf, tomato, pressed on French bread
Florida Straits Cuban
Slow roasted pulled pork, smoked pit ham, swiss cheese, barrel pickles and our homemade cuban style mustard. Served with a side of chimichurri black beans and yellow rice
Dexter's Tzatziki Lamb Burger
A blend of ground lamb and beef, lemon, garlic, oregano, grilled, topped with feta cheese, tzatziki, and toasted on an Old Hearth onion roll, LTO. Served with a Greek hot house cucumber salad
Grilled Pesto Chicken Sandwich
Havarti cheese, LTO, lemon-caper aioli, fresh herbs, pressed on an Old Hearth onion roll. Includes your choice of a classic Caesar or garden salad
House Made Truffle Fries
with a Parmesan scallion toss
Soup of the Moment
Available in: Bowl or Cup
Idaho Fries
Onion Rings
Steak Cut Fries
Sweet Potato Fries
Famous Turkey & Cheese Pinwheels
Boar's Head roasted turkey and Havarti cheese rolled up into fun pinwheels
Pasta Shell Bowl
Choose Marinara sauce, Alfredo sauce, or melted butter
Chicken Nugs
Smaller portion of our Famous Southern Dill Chicken Nugs
Mini Chicken & Cheese Quesadilla
6" tortillas stuffed with grilled chicken and melted mixed cheeses
Grilled Cheese
Colby cheddar cheese melted on Wheat Berry bread. Contains seeds
Kid's Burger
1⁄4 lb. grilled patty on a toasted bun. Cheese available upon request
Vista Point Pinot Grigio, California
Stella Rossa Bianco Sweet White, Italy
Shine Riesling, Rhinehessen, Germany
Magali Figuiere 'Cotes de Provence', France
Oyster Bay Sauvignon Blanc, New Zealand
Pomelo Sauvignon Blanc, California
Murphy Goode, California
Belle Ambiance Family Vineyards Pinot Noir, California
Belle Ambiance Family Vineyards Chardonnay, California
Dexter's Private Label Chardonnay, California
Woodbridge, California
Rodney Strong, Sonoma, California
Woop Woop Shiraz, South Australia
Hopes Ends Red Blend, Australia
Charles & Charles Red Blend, Washington State
Vidal Fleury Cotes du Rhone, France
Marques de Riscal Proximo, Rioja, Spain
Woodbridge Cabernet Sauvignon, California
Dexter's Private Label Cabernet, California
CK Mondavi and Family Merlot, California
Merf Cabernet Sauvignon, Washington
Ghostrunner, Ungrafted Red, California
Bellafina Prosecco, Italy
Quinta do Noval 'Black' Port, Portugal
Rombauer Carneros Napa Chardonnay, CA
Kistler Russian River Valley Pinot Noir, CA
Caymus Napa Valley Cabernet Sauvignon, CA
Faust Napa Valley Cabernet Sauvignon, CA
Shafer Napa Valley Cab Sauvignon Blend, CA
Vieuve Clicquot Brut 'Yellow Label' Champagne, FR
The Pamatini
Grey Goose Vodka, mixed with Pama Liquor, Triple Sec, and Cranberry, topped with a splash of Ginger Ale
Jalepeño Mango Margarita
Patron Silver, Triple Sec, sweet and sour mix, mango juice, fresh muddled lime and jalapeños, served on the rocks with a salted rim. Patron Reposado or Patron Anjeo
Espresso Martini
Creamy blend of vanilla vodka and espresso with whip cream topped with cinnamon
Dexter's Smokey Old Fashioned
First we smoke the glass, then we muddle an orange, cherry, sugar, and Angostura Bitters. Then we fill your choice Elijah Craig Small Batch Bourbon or Cask & Crew Rye Bourbon. A new smokey twist on an old favorite
The Acai-Blueberry Basil Martini
Absolute Berri Acai Vodka, fresh muddled basil, splash of sweet and sour, topped with a splash of Sierra Mist
The Dirty Dexter
Three ounces of chilled Tito's Handmade Vodka mixed with olive juice, garnished with house made Blue Cheese stuffed olives
The Rain Forest Martini
A refreshing blend of Svedka Vanilla Vodka, melon liquor, Malibu rum and pineapple juice. A taste of Spring in a glass
Mules Around the World
Your choice of Moscow Mule with Ketel One; Holland Mule with Nolet's Gin; or Irish Mule with Jameson Irish Whiskey; each made with Goslings Ginger Beer, lime and fresh mint
Budweiser
Bud Light
Coors Light
Michelob Ultra
Miller Light
Amstel Light
Angry Orchard (Hard Cider)
Blue Moon
Corona
Corona Light
Fat Tire
Guinness
Haake Beck (Non-Alcoholic)
Heineken
Tucher
Pepsi
Diet Pepsi
Sierra Mist
Dr Pepper
Ginger Ale
Lemonade
Luzianne Fresh Brewed Iced Tea
Cranberry
Mango
Peach
Lemonade
Coffee
Espresso
Dexter's Cuban Espresso
Cappuccino
Café Latte
Decaffeinated Coffee
Small San Pellegrino (16.9 oz)
Premium Spring Water
- $10.00
Artichoke Spinach Dip
Garlic Béchamel, Artichoke Hearts and Fresh Spinach topped with a Mediterranean Salsa served with crispy Tortilla Chips
- $12.00
Truffle Mushroom and Steak Flatbread
Sautéed Truffle scented Crimini Mushrooms. Roasted Tomatoes. Seared Filet Tips, Alfredo sauce and Fresh Spinach layered on a crispy Flatbread
- $21.00
Grilled Mahi a la Roma
Grilled Mahi topped with a Mediterranean Salsa served with a creamy Oven Roasted Tomato Orzo and wilted Spinach finished with a Tomato Caper Cream Sauce
- $21.00
Lobster and Chicken Florentine
Seared Chicken breast over a Parmesan Risotto stuffed Pesto-Balsamic marinated Portobello Mushroom topped with a Lobster Florentine Cream
- $22.00
Sweet and Smoky Salmon
Grilled Salmon served with Chipotle Cheddar Mashed Potatoes and Garlic braised Asparagus topped with a Bourbon Pecan Glaze
- $27.00
Dexter's Classic Filet
8 oz. Choice Filet cooked to your liking served with roasted Garlic Mashed Potatoes and sautéed Haricot Verts, Onions and Cherry Tomatoes finished with house made Demi-Glace
- $26.00
Scallops
Seared Sea Scallops served with herbed Orzo pilaf and Garlic Broccoli finished with a citrus cream sauce
- $12.00
Omelet Construction Center
Served with potato pancakes and fresh fruit garnish. Your choice of three items: Shrimp, Ham, Bacon, Breakfast Sausage, Onions, Tomatoes, Spinach, Mushrooms, Basil Pesto, Provolone Colby, Pepperjack, Swiss
- +Add for Additional Items
- $0.50
- $12.00
Farmland French Toast
Texas cut potato bread dipped in cinnamon French toast batter, served golden brown and sprinkled with powdered sugar. Served with a side of two eggs your way, bacon or sausage and crispy potato cakes
- $12.00
Dexter's Benedict
Toasted French bread layered with smoked turkey sliced tomatoes, sautéed spinach and two soft poached eggs topped with hollandaise. Severed with crispy potato cakes and fresh fruit garnish
- $12.00
Country Style Chicken & Biscuits
Country style buttermilk biscuits topped with our special seasoned fried chicken breast and homemade sausage gravy. Served with two eggs cooked to your liking
- $12.00
Breakfast Quesadilla of the Day
Crispy flour tortilla stuffed with an array of fresh breakfast items. Ask your server about what is inside! Served with crispy potato cakes
- $16.00
Ahi Tuna Poke Bowl*
Soy sesame ginger, marinated, rare Ahi tuna tossed with fresh avocado, green onions, and sesame seeds over Wakame seaweed salad served with crispy Wonton chips
- $16.00
The "Smith" Salmon Salad*
Arugula, mandarin oranges, sun-dried cranberries, pecans, red onions, tomatoes, Gorgonzola cheese, and olive oil-mustard vinaigrette
- $14.50
Blackened Chicken & Shrimp Salad
Mixed greens, roasted corn and herbed tomatoes, grilled red onions, dill cucumber slaw, asiago tortilla, and chunky blue cheese dressing
- $14.50
Blackened Salmon Tacos*
Three soft shell tortillas, avocado, black bean-corn salsa, cilantro cream cheese aioli
- $14.50
Spicy Shrimp Provencal
Pan seared shrimp seasoned with curry, fresh garlic and sweet chili, tossed with Capellini Pasta, tomato chunks and green onions. (Mild, Medium or Hot)
- $15.50
Kutza's Dockside Catch
Blackened Mahi, Key West tartar, lettuce, tomato, and onion ring on a butter toasted Brioche bun, served with Kickin' Old Bay Chips
- $14.50
Dexter's Tzatziki Lamb Burger
A blend of ground lamb and beef, lemon, garlic, oregano, grilled, topped with feta cheese, tzatziki, and toasted on an Old Hearth onion roll, lettuce tomato and onions. Served with a Greek hot house cucumber salad
- $12.00
Grilled Pesto Chicken Sandwich
Havarti cheese, lettuce tomato and onions, lemon-caper aioli, fresh herbs, pressed on an Old Hearth onion roll. Includes your choice of a classic Caesar or garden salad
- $12.50
Dexter's Famous Grilled Colby Cheeseburger
8 oz. Fresh ground burger topped with melted colby cheese, served with lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles on a toasted classic burger bun with Idaho fries
- +Add Bacon
- $1.50
- +Add Wild Mushrooms
- $1.00
- +Add Fried Egg
- $1.50
Eggs a' la Carte
- (2)
- $2.50
- $1.75
Toast or Biscuit
Cheddar Grits
- Sm
- $2.00
- Lg
- $4.00
- $4.00
Potato Cakes
Fresh Flavored Mimosas
Raspberry, Mango, Peach, Orange, Cranberry, Pineapple
- Endless
- $12.00
- Double
- $6.50
- Single
- $5.25
- $8.00
Dexter's Ultimate Bloody Mary
Zing Zang Bloody Mary mix, house pepper infused vodka, bacon salt rim and a stuffed olive, cucumber, sport pepper skewer
- $2.85
Espresso
- $2.95
Dexter's Cuban Espresso
- $4.25
Cappuccino
- $4.25
Café Latte
Pepsi
Diet Pepsi
Sierra Mist
Dr Pepper
Ginger Ale
Lemonade
Fresh Brewed Iced Tea
Cranberry
Mango
Peach
Lemonade
- $14.00
Dexter's Crab Cakes
Pan fried house made crab cakes served with Mustard Vinaigrette tossed Micro greens and topped with an Old Bay Remoulade
- $10.00
Artichoke Spinach Dip
Garlic Bechamel, Artichoke Hearts and Fresh Spinach topped with a Mediterranean Salsa served with crispy Tortilla Chips
- $12.00
Truffle Mushroom and Steak Flatbread
Sautéed Truffle scented Crimini Mushrooms, Roasted Tomatoes, Seared Filet Tips, Alfredo sauce and Fresh Spinach layered on a crispy Flatbread
- $25.00
Fire Grilled Chimichurri Teres Major
Grilled Teres Major sliced and topped with Chimichurri served with Fiesta Street Corn and a fire roasted Poblano cream sauce
- $19.00
Shrimp and Lobster Pasta Bake
Sautéed Shrimp and Lobster tossed with shell pasta and a pesto tomato cream sauce, roasted Eggplant and chunks of Tomatoes accompanied with Garlic Bread Crostini's
- $22.00
Mediterranean Grilled Salmon
Grilled Salmon served with Lemon Orzo Primavera and Sautéed Spinach finished with a Tomato Caper cream
- $21.00
Lobster and Chicken Florentine
Seared Chicken breast over a Parmesan Risotto stuffed Pesto-Balsamic marinated Portobello Mushroom topped with a Lobster Florentine Cream
- $28.00
Dexter's Classic Filet
8 oz. Choice Filet cooked to your liking served with Parmesan Confit Potatoes and Garlic grilled Asparagus finished with house made Mushroom Demi-Glace

TRENDING ON GAYOT.com
-
CHAMPAGNE: Do you know who invented Brut Champagne? Read the article.
-
RECIPE: Dairy-free deviled eggs for Mother's Day Brunch. Get the recipe.
-
COCKTAILS: Add bubbles to your Mother's Day Brunch with these colorful champagne cocktails. Get the recipes.
-
HEALTH: Why you should add eggs to your diet. Read the article.
Check out GAYOT's list of Best Spring Beers to find crisp brews, wheat ales and American IPAs. Check the list.
GAYOT's list of the Best 10 Superfoods covers the most health-promoting fruits, veggies, seeds and spices. Read the article.